Fresh | Flavorful | Affordable

Enjoy a mouthwatering meal at our family restaurant in New Paltz, NY

Sink Your Teeth Into Something Delicious

You’ll always get a great meal at our family restaurant in New Paltz, NY

When you’re hungry and only wings will do, make your way to McGillicuddy’s. We serve tender cooked chicken wings every day of the week. You can choose from a wide range of sweet and spicy wing sauces that are sure to hit the spot.

Not in the mood for wings? Don’t sweat it. We also serve a variety of burgers, salads and sandwiches. We serve patrons from New Paltz, NY and surrounding areas.

Sink Your Teeth Into Something Delicious

There’s no need to search far and wide for a family-friendly restaurant. When you need a spot the whole family will love, make your way to McGillicuddy’s. We have something for even the pickiest eaters.

Some of our regulars love our:

Want to unwind with a cold one? We’ve got plenty of beer on tap. Visit our family restaurant today for lunch or dinner.

Come one Come All Join the Greatest Show in New Paltz!

We’re excited to announce the grand opening of Sideshow Kitchen & Bar, a brand-new dining destination in New Paltz, NY! As we prepare to serve our community delicious, high-quality food and exceptional service, we’re looking for talented, passionate, and motivated individuals to join our team.

Menu

Satisfy your cravings with our famous burgers and wings.

Party Buffet Menu

Nothing fires up a party like buffet catering.

Catering Menu

The party is portable with McGillicuddy's event catering.

Weekly Events

Find something new in store every night of the week.

Serving all your American favorites

Don’t settle for second-rate starters. Start your night off right with an order of savory garlic fries or honey BBQ wings for the whole table. We serve fresh and flavorful food at our restaurant in New Paltz, NY.

Hungry for a delicious meal but don’t want to leave the house? We also offer takeout and delivery options. Just call in your order and enjoy your wings from the comfort of your home.

Open for Dine-In, Pickup and Delivery.

Try our award-winning wings

Draft Beer Menu

Late Night Menu

Hours: Sunday - Thursday 9-11pm, Friday - Saturday 10pm-11

In-House Catering Menu

FULL MENU

Kids Menu